Katharine McPhee gets the sweet spot tonight, and her "Someone To Watch Over Me" is everything you'd expect, though I'm not sure I agree with Simon that she made everyone else look like "amateurs." (Quick, someone refill his Coke glass.)

Interesting that the best theme nights of "Idol" so far have involved music written long, long before any of the contestants was born.

I'm still waiting, though, for The Moment -- Fantasia singing "Summertime" remaining the gold standard -- that makes me shiver.