Katharine smartly chooses "Can't Help Falling in Love," which should be a show-stopper and right up her alley, to boot.

And then, as she sometimes does, she oversings it, with the middle part particularly bad.

Which is not something you want to do with one of the most beautiful songs Elvis, or anyone, ever sang.

"Apple pie and a gallon of cream on top," declares Simon, who must not like too much cream on his apple pie.

If there's any justice in "Idol," we'll be looking at an all-boy contest after this week.

(And if not, Elliott's going out on one of his best weeks.)