Philadelphia Daily News

    « Writing - Good for Health | Main | Vioxx Scandal »


    Why is your workout not working?... & more questions

    THANK YOU for the e-mail comments, suggestions and questions. This week's column answers some of your most frequently asked questions.
    The secret to fit abs

    Q: What is the secret to getting sexy abs? I do a series of abdominal exercises for 30 to 45 minutes for four to five days a week and still I don't see so much as a ripple.

    - John W.

    A: Ahhhh... the abs, America's most coveted body part. Well, John, I've got good news and bad news. The bad news first... you'll never get the six-pack or lose those love handles doing ab exercises alone. There is no single exercise to give you a slamming six-pack.

    The secret to getting awesome abs is multifaceted. First you must consider your genetics. Are you apple- or pear-shaped?

    You're an apple if you primarily gain your weight in the upper body and tummy area. If you gain primarily in the hips, buttocks and thighs, you're a pear with a naturally small waist.

    Generally speaking, pears have the natural upper hand (having the smaller waist) but pears can lose their advantage and turn into an apple when excess weight is gained.

    Even when you factor in genetics, which accounts for about 20 percent of your appearance, you still have a full 80 percent of which you control.

    Secondly, you must study your diet closely. Eating either too little or too much will sabotage your success. Eating small frequent meals throughout the day will keep the metabolic furnace burning and aid in whittling away the fat.

    Thirdly, be sure to get sufficient cardiovascular and resistance training to burn off fat and shape lean muscle.

    So, there you have it! The secrets to a six-pack are a combination of strength training, proper nutrition, and adequate cardio.

    Weight loss woes

    Q: For the past eight months I've been jogging on the treadmill three-four times a week for 30 minutes and weight training two times a week and have seen no results. I have not lost a pound. What am I doing wrong?

    - Sabrina J.

    A: Congratulations on making the commitment and sticking with an exercise program. It's all good. Even though you may not see it, your body is thanking you in ways other than weight loss.

    It sounds to me that you have one or possibly two of the following three problems:

    • Low-intensity cardio and weight training.

    • Eating too little.

    • Eating too much.

    Cardio training

    Many people exercise regularly, but the question you must ask yourself is how effective is your exercise routine.

    You must give yourself quantifiable goals. You must develop goals and quantify them with numbers. For example, under weight loss you must put a number, let's say 20 pounds, and figure out how long it will take you to take off 20 pounds in a safe and healthy manner. Through strength training, your goal may be to be able to perform 10-20 push-ups consecutively, for example .

    Otherwise you are just wishing for results as opposed to goal-setting, planning and tracking your success. A wish requires no action on your part, but a plan does.

    Also, remember that the body adjusts to your routine. Perhaps it is time to increase the speed or length of time on the treadmill or to increase the intensity of your weight-training program. Try adding a third day of weight training, doing either a high-weight, low-rep routine or interval training.

    Calories too low

    Many people mistakenly keep their calories too low in an effort to accelerate weight loss. Semi-starvation diets and low-calorie diets increase the body's stress levels, increase cortisol levels and virtually shut down the metabolism. A sluggish or shut-down metabolism will not burn stored energy (fat). Decreasing calories too much makes the body hold onto fat while simultaneously burning your precious muscle.

    Eating too much

    I suppose most people will fall into this category. Many people wrongly think that if they exercise that gives them the license to eat whatever they want. This is not true. Exercise or not, if you consume more calories than you burn each day you will gain weight. Where you gain the weight is based on your genetics.

    On the other hand, if you create a caloric deficit by taking in slightly fewer calories each day you will lose weight. To further illustrate, the average woman jogging on the treadmill for 30 minutes will burn between 150-200 calories. Two hundred calories is the equivalent to eating one slice of toast with one pat of butter.

    Without a doubt, we can always eat more calories than we lose when we work out. If weight loss is one of your goals, then you'll need to pay close attention to your workout as well as your caloric intake.

    No fat-low carb follies

    Q: I eat a no-fat and low-carbohydrate plan and still I appear to be gaining weight. Why?

    - Joan L.

    A: First of all, dump all of those no-fat, low-fat, no-carb, low-carb diet fads. In the long run, they do not work and in the end, could do more harm than good.

    Get back to the basics with fruits, vegetables, whole grains and lean protein. There's just no substitute for good-quality foods.

    When it comes to weight loss, it's always a case of calories in, vs. calories out. If you want results, you need to be aware of what works. I recommend keeping a detailed food diary. You'll be surprised at how many calories you really are taking in. If you mind your meals, you're sure to see results.

    Body fat is too high?

    Q: I recently lost 60 pounds and now weigh 130 pounds. Now that I've lost the weight I thought this was a good time to start working with a trainer. I'm very frustrated, however, because the trainer said my body fat was very high at 40 percent. He said a body fat percentage of 21-24 percent is considered "fit." How is this possible? Is he right?

    - Tina A.

    A: Most people using commercial weight loss programs lose weight very rapidly. Losing weight rapidly is rarely beneficial because rapid weight loss decreases your metabolism, increases the body's stress hormones, decreases your strength, and cannibalizes your muscle.

    When it comes to body fat analysis, your trainer is both right and wrong. According to the American Council on Exercise, a body fat of 21-24 percent is considered "fit" for women, but ACE also states that up to 30 percent is acceptable.

    No question, you need to lower your body fat. Take your time and follow your trainer's counsel. *

    Posted on August 24, 2005 4:56 PM | Permalink

    Comments (4)

    Yvonne W:

    I workout at least five days a week. My problem is
    my diet.
    However, I take full responsibility for that and am now trying to instill healthier eating habits into my everyday routine.
    I was doing well until I went to Puerto Rico a couple of weeks ago. Once I break my routine it's hard for me to get back on track.
    The older you get the harder it is to take weight off and keep it off.
    I'll be 58 in December and weight didn't become a struggle until I was 46 years old. However, that was probably because I started working out at 28 years old and was not fully aware of the benefits.

    Posted by Yvonne W | August 25, 2005 12:20 AM

    Posted on August 25, 2005 00:20

    Tommye:

    My problem, stomach . I am 5 1/4 " tall,small frame, I weigh 118 lbs. I do not need to lose weight. I am thin except for stomach. What do I need to do.

    Posted by Tommye | October 22, 2005 6:56 PM

    Posted on October 22, 2005 18:56

    Robert Thompson:

    Can you explain what glycemic load is, and why is it different from low carb.

    Posted by Robert Thompson | March 26, 2006 9:51 PM

    Posted on March 26, 2006 21:51

    Kelly:

    I've been working with a personal trainer for the past 6 weeks. I started at 195, I lost 2 pounds after 3 weeks. But, now I'm up to 197. I don't know what it going wrong. I'm eating very well, lots of lean protein, good carbs, six small meals, I get sleep, I do weight training with my trainer and I do cardio on the days she's not with me. What am I doing wrong? I'm working so hard, yet it seems like I'm going in the wrong diretion and feeling VERY frustrated. I'm not giving up, by no means, but I want to know how to get the scale to start going the other direction. A trainer isn't cheap and I want results. She's great, she works me good and hard. What's up with my body?

    Posted by Kelly | June 28, 2006 4:19 PM

    Posted on June 28, 2006 16:19