(Here is a longer version of a review appearing in Tuesday's Inquirer)
By Peter Dobrin
INQUIRER MUSIC CRITIC
You don’t notice the greatness at first. Yevgeniy Sharlat’s Piano Quartet, unveiled at an Astral concert Sunday afternoon, starts with melodies that must be deduced, almost like one of those pixilated puzzles whose image can only be seen if you stand back far enough.
But then patterns begin to emerge. You get the sense that material is being taken apart, put back together. Those patterns begin to emit a certain mood. And in places the mood grows quite emotional. I was particularly taken with the section in which the viola pizzicato accompanies a piano music-box part – only to be interrupted by a bright outburst, a contradiction, from the piano. Here you were sure the two instruments were saying something to each.
That’s often the definition of greatness in music – when something as abstract as pure tone starts to tap you on the shoulder with a message to look outside of music, and this new work does that emphatically. Sharlat, born in Moscow and educated at Yale, Curtis and Juilliard, was commissioned to write his Piano Quartet by Astral Artistic Services, and it might be one of the most compelling works to enter the chamber music literature in some time. His aesthetic is unique, and yet it evolves even during the course of the work. Some sections build in intensity. Elsewhere, so little happens that the instruments pretty much loiter – until the piano comes along with a slap of sound. There’s something creepy and generally disorienting about one movement, where nothing seems to resolve but rather merely relents when it gets taken over by another idea. At one point the piece totally dissolves into a moment of deep despair when the piano descends into the far reaches of the bass.
Sharlat creates a section where the four instruments almost ignore each other. Their self-involvement might be complete, until you notice it’s all adding up to a wonderful rhythmically charged drone. And this is where the composer leaves you off, with a distinct Brahms-meets-Gorecki intensity.
The piece is dedicated to Andrius Zlabys, the impressive Astral pianist who recruited guest violinist Pavel Ilyashov, violist Anton Jivaev and cellist Wendy Warner for this Philadelphia premiere at the Trinity Center (the world premiere was given Saturday night at a community music school in Trappe, Pa.).
The musicians played the new score with the kind of confidence that only comes with efficient rehearsing, and which was less obvious in some of the other works on the program. Three of the players gave the local premiere of Dmitri Levkovich’s Piano Trio – the first movement of which was like a more impressionistic Rachmaninoff Vocalise, with a second movement fugue on a rather Shostakovichian theme.
Astral also commissioned Luis Prado’s Piano Quintet, “Suite de Baile,” infused with Spanish folk tunes and perhaps more cheery than some of the music audiences here might remember from the composer’s days in Philadelphia (he lives in Madrid now). The first movement, “Procesión,” was especially effecting, an evocation of a passing band whose music is heard only partially as it approaches and departs.
Heard even more distantly, in Mahler’s early and unfinished Piano Quartet, was the Mahler we know. I’m glad to have heard the piece, which developed its material in a narrow and unimaginative way, if only to be cheered by the reminder that genius is one of those things that sometimes strikes later in life.
Contact music critic Peter Dobrin at 215-854-5611 or pdobrin@phillynews.com. Read his blog at http://go.philly.com/artswatch.