The trade proposals that our amateur GM’s make on this blog continue to draw tremendous interest. We’ll look at some of the proposed trades and try to answer some of the questions posed. (By the way, if anybody wants a personal response to any comments, the best way is to email - mnarducci@phillynews.com)
Item: Dean, a regular on the blog, has proposed this trade with Memphis
The Sixers receive Mike Miller and Kyle Lowry and Memphis gets Willie Green, Kevin Ollie, Jason Smith and a 2009 first round pick.
Response: If I’m Memphis, I wouldn’t do that trade. If I were the Sixers, it would be done in a split second.We know the Sixers like both Miller and Lowry, but so do many other teams. It wouldn’t be surprising if at least one if not both are dealt by the trade deadline.
Memphis would be receiving an expiring contract with Ollie, the potential in Jason Smith and a guard in Willie Green who really wouldn’t fit into the Grizzlies plans.
Lowry brings toughness and could develop into a top defensive player, but his offensive game is still a work in progress.
Miller is bordering on all-star status and if he played on a better team, he might get consideration. He played last summer on the U.S. National Team and it wouldn’t be surprising to see him in the Olympics. He is one of the best shooters in the league, but he can also create his own shot.
Having him at the two-guard and Andre Iguodala at the small forward would be a good combo. It’s just that Memphis should get much more for him, although the same was said about Pau Gasol.
Item: After pointing out that the Sixers have outscored teams, 87-49 in the fourth quarter during their four-game win streak, one reader asked about the differential in bench scoring during the streak.
Response: The Sixers bench has outscored opponents, 118-68 during this streak. The only time the bench scoring was even close came against Dallas, when the Sixers reserves held a 22-20 advantage.
Item: Joe Doc proposes a three-way trade among the Sixers, Golden State and Cleveland. The Cavs would get Andre Miller and Calvin Booth, Golden State would receive Drew Gooden and Willie Green and the Sixers would acquire Ira Newble, Brandon Wright, Patrick O’Bryant and a first round pick from both.
Response: There is logic in this deal, but if I were the Sixers, I wouldn’t go near it. If I’m giving up Andre Miller, I want more than a couple of expiring contracts and a young power forward such as Wright, who may never develop a back to basket game. And the first round picks will be past the midway point. For Miller to get traded, I’ve said it before the Sixers need a quality player back. That leads us to our next item.
Item: Not only wouldn’t I trade Miller by the deadline, but would think about beginning talks to extend him.
Response: While Miller would like to play for a playoff team, he has been enjoying working with this young group. And Miller, while not one to seek or enjoy attention, seems taken back by all the praise he has been receiving lately. He seems almost embarrassed, but also appreciative. A point guard who knows how to play the game is a precious commodity and as I stated in the paper last week, maybe the best team for Miller is the one he is on.
Item: Dean had another trade proposal that was interesting, but one I wouldn’t do if I were Ed Stefanski. Here is the proposal:
Sacramento gets the Sixers 2009 first round pick and Utah’s conditional first rounder that it owes the Sixers along with Jason Smith, Kevin Ollie and Rodney Carney. The Sixers would get Ron Artest and Beno Udrich.
Response: While there is no questioning Artest’s talent, he has had too many blowups to be considered reliable. The Sixers have done a good job of bringing in character players who aren’t head cases. Artest simply can’t be counted on. Udrith is probably a better than solid point guard who has really hurt the Sixers. He had 15 points – all in the second half and eight assists when the Kings won in Philadelphia. When the Sixers won in Sacramento, he had 19 points and six assists. Another intereseting proposal, but one we wouldn’t do.
Item: A person named Theo wrote that Andre Iguodala has the potential of being a special player.
Response: We totally agree. Iguodala has taken many hits, mainly because of the contract demands. If that is taken out of the mix, look how much he does on a nightly basis. And his defensive contribution shouldn’t be minimized. Sure, there is plenty about his offensive game that has to grow, but this year he has become more comfortable with his outside shot. The handle is a work in progress, but it will continue to get better. It’s the opinion here that Iguodala may be among the fans one of the more unappreciated players in Philadelphia.
Item: Iguodala mentioned that Wednesday’s game with Memphis could be a trap game.
Response: It sure can and the Sixers have to watch out. It was stated here that winning four of five on this homestand would be a success, but now with the four in the bag, nothing short of five will do.
That’s because Memphis will be playing the second of a back to back games and traveling to Philadelphia after hosting Sacramento.
What is a little worrisome is that the Sixers have been fielding a lot of questions from the media recently about their playoff run and how well they have done recently. Keep in mind, the Sixers haven’t accomplished anything except to put themselves in a position to keep playing meaningful games. The Memphis game will be a test to see if the Sixers can stay focused and not get caught up in all the positive press they have been receiving.