Maybe it was Jessica's Winter's provocative essay about Al Pacino. Maybe it was because The Godfather and Scarface have been in heavy rotation on cable.
But I've been thinking hard about Pacino's evolution as an actor. (That's him as The Godfather Michael Corleone in the fedora, and as Ocean's 13 adversary Willie Bank in the Pepto Bismol pink tie).
Admittedly I roll my eyes at the screen when Pacino exaggeratedly rolls his in one of his bombastic performances ( Ocean's and Scent of a Woman ). But to paraphrase a Pacino line, just when I think I can count him out, he pulls me back in.
Has any other actor of his generation created (or reinterpreted) more memorable characters? Michael Corleone. Frank Serpico. Sonny (in Dog Day Afternoon). Tony Montana. Ricky Roma. Carlito Brigante. Big Boy Caprice (Dick Tracy.) Lowell Bergman (In The Insider.) Lt. Hanna (Heat). Tony D'Amato (Any Given Sunday). Roy Cohn (Angels in America.) Shylock. And, no offense to Jack Nicholson, Pacino was the creepiest and most debauched movie Satan ever (The Devil's Advocate).
While Winter is correct in observing that lately Pacino is often more the overactor than the actor, barking lines like an overexcited terrier, she fails to suggest why.
My hunch is that with all the cosmetic surgery Pacino seems to have had, he has seriously compromised his greatest instrument, that most expressive face. His performances are increasingly dependent on his voice. (I have no hard evidence that he has had surgery. But look at his movies from Sea of Love forward and you'll note the eyes, cheeks and jowls are more sculpted, less mobile.) Some recent Pacino performances remind me of those Clutch Cargo cartoon where only the characters' lips move.
Am I alone in thinking that those performers -- and I include Meg Ryan of the collagen lips and Michael Douglas of the lifted and chiseled jawline -- who try to save face by going under the knife are knifing their most precious asset?
Your thoughts? Favorite Pacino performances? Pacino or Nicholson? Show all work.