« Godiva goes Turkish | Main | Cigna speaks on Sarkisyan »

Cigna's transplant crisis

sarkisyan.JPG
Nataline Sarkisyan
   
Nataline Sarkisyan, the California teen-ager whose family was pleading with Cigna Corp. for a transplant, has died. This end is tragic. And yes, it lets Cigna off the hook of paying for her procedure and care as it agreed yesterday. But it could throw the insurer, run by Ed Hanway, from the frying pan into the fire, because the family is now threatening to sue it. Nothing quite as bad as a mourning mother accusing your company of "maliciously killing" her daughter.

The nurses association, which led protests against Cigna on Sarkisyan's behalf, has put out a statement blasting the insurance company and accusing it of perpetrating "a horrific tragedy that demonstrates what is so fundamentally wrong with our health care system today."

Note that this girl, according to the AP, was in a vegetative state. She had leukemia. Her doctors recommended a new liver only after the bone marrow transplant procedure that they performed had failed. Our question: If it was a such a viable life-saving measure, why didn't the hospital just do it and eat the cost itself, under an uncompensated care financing system that every state has? There are way too many questions about this case to draw conclusions.

We've put in a call to Cigna, which had not commented on the situation since the teen-ager died after it said Thursday that it would cover the procedure.

- Thomas Ginsberg

Comments (3)

Cherri:

Money Up Front??? What happend to the fact that the hospital had a liver available, but refused to transplant without money up front? If this hospital was truely concerned about the patient and not their money, they would have provided the transplant, and then followed up on the appeal process through the insurance. Let's put the real blame where it lies, on the hospital for being money hungry, not on the insurance company for administering the policies benefits like they were suppose to........

tom johnson:

Anybody out there got access to the Cigna corporate email list?

If you work for Cigna, you do. Just download the corporate email list from your email reader at work (Outlook or whatever) and email it to your external email account (gmail, hotmail, whatever).

Then post the file on-line (along with job titles), so we can all express our holiday wishes directly to the individuals involved.

Any questions on how to do this, email me at corporateweasels@gmail.com.

Steve :

Who eventually received the liver? What if that person had been denied the liver because of Natalines's receiving the liver -- and if Nataline's chances of survival on receiving the liver were so much less then the "next" in line is that really the right use for a very need resource? What about the hospital could it not have absorbed the cost of the transplant and then later argued it out with the insurer especially if it was successful thus proving their "plea" accurate? In Philadelphia -- at Einstein Hospital many people from New York and New Jersey are receiving new livers here in a Philly Hospital because the "waiting list" in New York City area is so great. How can the people in Philly who need a liver transplant be absolutely sure that their "Philly Liver" is not going to a New Yorker simply because they can afford or have better medical coverage. Transplants very well may bring out the best in us -- the offer to give a new life to someone, and the worst in us because we may come to believe that our life should be preserved over another's.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Contributors


About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on December 21, 2007 5:38 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Godiva goes Turkish.

The next post in this blog is Cigna speaks on Sarkisyan.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.35