Kudos for Toll's "stinky" quarter
Instead of getting blasted for reporting lousy quarterly results, Toll Brothers Inc. (NYSE: TOL) Chief Executive Robert Toll is getting kudos because they weren't nearly as bad as Wall Street expected.
BusinessWeek remarked that the Horsham company can "take a punch." Toll shares rose more than 5 percent yesterday and continued to rise today. JMP Securities analyst James Wilson raised his rating on the stock to market perform (about a C) from market underperform (a failing grade).
Toll got into the good graces of investors because Wall Street analysts expected it to lose money in the quarter. Instead, it posted a profit of 16 cents. Toll also indicated that it wasn't having trouble getting so-called jumbo loans funded. These loans are more difficult to sell to investors because they exceed the $417,000 limit set by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
In the world of Wall Street, Robert Toll hit a grand slam home run.
But Toll's results were still pretty bad even if they weren't awful as analysts expected. Profit fell 85 percent and cancellations were their highest in the company's 21-year history as a public company. Robert Toll told analysts on the earnings conference call that traffic to the company's developments has been "stinky." The company also declined to give earnings guidance given the shaky state of the market.
Eventually, the real estate market will rebound and Toll's financial position will improve, JMP's Wilson wrote in a note today to clients. When that will happen, though, isn't clear.
"We believe Toll is uniquely positioned as the only national production builder of luxury housing," JMP's Wilson wrote in a note to clients. "However, in today's weak housing environment, in which significant volume and price contraction is occurring, we expect its highly discretionary luxury product segment to take longer to register renewed growth than other parts of the housing market."
Lawrence Rothman of the Motley Fool cautions that investors may be overly optimistic.
"Some onlookers may have also parsed Robert Toll's words, taken a positive-sounding comment, and run with it," he wrote.
Toll Bros.' vice chairman Bruce Toll also is chairman of Philadelphia Media Holdings L.L.C., which owns The Inquirer, Philadelphia Daily News, Philly.com and this blog. He is the brother of Robert Toll.

Nicholas S. Schorsch, who was ousted last year from the REIT he founded,
Toll Brothers Inc. (
That's a Bryn Mawr home of Jack Bogle, founder of
Remember the old caveat to beware a guy offering to sell you the Brooklyn Bridge? Now there's a new twist, so says the
Speaking of the housing slowdown: