Battle over Mace is coming to a head?
| PhillyInc incorrectly reported that Mace shareholder Andrew Shapiro had called on Mace board chairman Louis Paolino Jr. to remove his brother Matthew from the board. Shapiro actually made the request to the full board. |
![]() |
"For the second year in a row, Mace has experienced weakness in its internal controls and errors in financial reporting that have not only delayed its SEC filings to the point of a threatened delisting of its stock but have also forced Mace to incur substantial (but) undisclosed costs. ... We believe that the company has incurred millions of dollars in investigative and legal expense as the result of these matters and that these costs do not include the disruption to the company's business and harm to its brand and reputation. There is simply no excuse for such poor board oversight at a public company in today's governance environment."
PhillyInc put in a call today to Mace, but no answer yet. Lawndale hit a chord on Wall Street: News of its demands today sent Mace's shares up more than 5 percent, to $2.57 from $2.44.
In January, Kelly Capital, another investor, offered $45.8 million for the company. That bid, which equaled $3 per share, was rejected as too low. Mace then asked Kelly if it would consider raising its bid, but it declined. Kelly Capital's senior vice president, Joe Altman, told PhillyInc he is still prohibited by a confidentiality agreement from discussing details of his company's discussions with Mace. His company no longer owns Mace shares.
Mace's shares have rebounded slightly this year, up about 2 percent, as the company continued selling off a national car-wash chain which Paolino tried to build up. But Shapiro insists the stock price doesn't adequately reflect the value of the company. As if putting his money where his mouth is, Shapiro has now increased Lawndale's stake in Mace to 9.3 percent from 7.5 percent in December.
Shapiro isn't alone in his criticism of Mace's management. Proxy advisers Glass Lewis & Co. L.L.C. and Institutional Shareholder Services criticized the company's compensation committee for negotiating a three-year deal with Paolino that gave him stock options that vested immediately instead of over several years, which is more typical. Paolino also can receive bonuses for both buying and selling businesses, which shareholders argued encouraged him to do deals that were not in the best interest of shareholders, a criticism rejected by Mace.
At the company's shareholder meeting in December, Lawndale and No. 2 shareholder Ancora Capital withheld their votes from the incumbent directors, including Drexel University President Constantine Papadakis. The directors were approved by 71 percent of the shareholders. Directors typically receive more than 90 percent in these types of votes.
Lawndale's candidates for its proposed three new board seats are: Eugene I. Davis, chief executive of Pirinate Consulting Group, L.L.C., which among other things specializes in restructuring companies (Davis also happens to sit on the board of Foamex L.P. in Linwood, Pa.); JL Development Co.'s chief executive Gerald T. LaFlamme, who oversees a real estate development and consulting firm; and Donald R. Raefied of Edge Integration Systems Inc., who Lawndale says has more than 25 years experience in the security industry. As for Shapiro's own ties with his candidates, he told PhillyInc in an interview that he serves on a board with LaFlamme but has no business connections with Davis or Raefield. Lawndale is based in Mill Valley, Calif.



Nicholas S. Schorsch, who was ousted last year from the REIT he founded,
The saga continues: The No. 2 shareholder in Mace Security International Inc. (
For leaders in the Latino community such as Will Gonzalez, these are challenging times. Not only is the public demanding immigration reform, but economic problems such as the meltdown in the subprime mortgage market threaten to eat away at the economic gains Latinos have made in recent years. Gonzalez runs
Robert Isom, the recently appointed operations chief at