At first, I was going to post pieces of this letter voicing frustration with the often-under-fire Streets Department. But so well written, I've posted it below in its entirety. Thanks for venting, Stephanie, and you're right, this is a great insight to the short dumping issue.
"A little insight into why short dumping is such a problem in Philadelphia: Yesterday my household trash was not picked up as scheduled. Everyone else on our block puts out several plastic bags, which typically spill trash all over the sidewalk. My husband and I put our trash in a sturdy trash can with a lid that we bought at the local big box home store. We thought we were doing the right thing by neatly containing our trash.
A phone call to the Streets Department revealed that our trash can is too big and that the sanitation department will not pick up “construction debris.” We are remodeling our powder room, and our trash can contained a few dry wall remnants, all contained in trash bags.
In our house, we create one bag, maybe two, in a one week period. All of our other neighbors create 4 or more bags of trash, with the exception of our neighbor next door. There is clearly excess capacity because the sanitation department will, according to their literature, pick up six 32-gallon containers or twelve 26-to-32 gallon leak-proof bags at each address.
If you call for a special bulk pick up, the city will take it. They will take up to 2 tires. You can even drop off the bulk items at free Convenience Centers. But in no case will they take small bits of wood and drywall. And oh, by the way, "you can be fined for that," the lady at the Streets Department says about putting out drywall on your collection day.
So, what is the legal solution, you ask? You have to take the construction debris to a private dump that charges a minimum of $70 for up to one ton of trash. If you are paying cash, you must give them a $100 deposit from which they will deduct your charge when you leave. And the dump is only open until 6pm on weekdays. And only one dump in the south side of the city is open on the weekend- Saturday from 6am -12noon. If you do not have a pick up truck or a van, then you have to rent one of those too. The system clearly is not set up for the home or small business owner, who probably create the majority of waste that is short-dumped.
In the end it probably all goes to the same dump. It's just that the legal way to dispose of small debris will cost you $100-150, including the value of your time. Or the illegal way is free.
This is why short dumping is such a problem in this city."