« Guru Takes a Technological Time-Out | Main | Rutgers Seniors Bid Adieu Discussing Their Legacy »

Guru's Musings: Atlantic Ten Logjam Looms at the Finish

By Mel Greenberg

Now La Salle coach Tom Lochner knows what life would be like at the close of the season if he had a similar job in the NFL.

"The Atlantic Ten is so competitive through the middle that if we lose Saturday night, we're the 13th seed and staying home from the conference tournament. But if we win, we could move up as high as the ninth seed," Lochner said from the team bus Friday night on the way to Pittsburgh to play Duquesne in what will be the last A-10 game of the day to determine the tournament seeds.

"Only a few points in a bunch of games have affected everything for us and other teams. We're going to approach the game against a good Duquesne team with the same purpose we do every game, although obviously there's more of an urgency among our seniors."

One of them -- Carlene Hightower -- is likely to land on the All-Atlantic Ten first team, even if Saturday night becomes her final collegiate performance.

Duquesne, incidentally, is coached by former Penn State star Suzie McConnell-Serio in her first season. Not given seriously consideration for the vacancy that opened at her alma mater last spring, who would have forecasted that her team at this hour has one more win than the Nittany Lions.

A victory over La Salle puts McConell-Serio's team in the tournament. Penn State, meanwhile, is on a school-record nine-game losing streak after a promising start under new coach Coquesne Washington, a quality hire who will eventually get the program back to respectability.

Meanwhile, The A-10 office, located here in Philadelphia, could quickly use some experienced loggers, and they're not talking about the modern day ones with internet expertise.

A mammoth logjam looms ahead to determine the seeds for next weekend's conference tournament here at St. Joseph's.

The Atlantic Ten has taken family ties to a new extreme all over the standings.

Only Fordham, on a path to dubious history in Washington Saturday afternoon, has made everything precisely clear without further need for mathematical comparisons.

The Rams (0-28), which have long since been eliminated from tournament participation, will be a heavy underdog at George Washington, which is tied for first with Temple. A loss will make Fordham the first team to ever finish at 0-29.

Unfortunately, the government is closed on the weekends.Thus, President Bush won't be traveling to the Smith Center for postgame ceremonies to declare Fordham a disaster area eligible for federal recovery funds for the Rams' recruiting budget.

If the NCAA held a collegiate draft of high school players, Wilmington's Elena Delle Donne would be heading for a future reputation as a Bronx bomber in New York City rather than one in the frozen tundra as a Connecticut Husky in Storrs.

Speaking of Storrs, Jonathan is making his first visit to the thirving suburb of Hartford to visit a friend at UConn and reported back of his initial impression: "This place is a cow town." Then, unaware of the obvious, he noted that he currently was at a dining place called "The Dairy Bar."

"Makes sense to me," your Guru responded.

Incidentally, Fordham is a case in point of why the RPI should not be an end-all.

While the Rams are being portrayed in the media as the worst-team ever, although the effort and desire of coach Cathy Andruzzi's players would tell a different story, the RPI simulations indicate that 11 teams can be found with a ranking lower than Fordham's 327.

Meanwhile, a quirk of league scheduling combined with team performances, have produced a fascinating afternoon for a conference that many refer to as mid-major, which might be a mis-identification.

The Guru is not going to supplant the conference in explaining every situation but will now take a look at things from the perspective of the three local members -- Temple, St. Joseph's, and, as mentioned, where the real fun exists: La Salle.

George Washington, the overwhelming conference favorite, is looking for help from Massachusetts against Temple, here at the Liacouras Center, to recover the top seed.

The Colonials held that spot in a three-way deadlock before Xavier lost a second time this season Wednesday night to Dayton, dropping the Musketeers to third.

That propelled Temple, which was looking at a No. 3 seed, to the No. 1 seed, because the Owls' win over George Washington gives them the tie-breaker. So the Colonials will be a No. 1 or No. 2, depending on the Owls, who could have the last laugh on a preseason conference poll picking them fourth.

If Temple, the lone city hope for an NCAA tournament bid, loses and Xavier beats St. Bonaventure, the Owls drop to third seed because of their loss to the Musketeers. Or they hold a nmumber two seed with a loss and a St. Bonaventure upset of the Musketeers.

St. Joseph's, which will host Rhode Island, is sixth no matter what, playing the last game at 6 p.m.on Friday's opening day of competition.

The Hawks can finish in a three-way tie for fourth with Dayton and Charlotte if both lose Saturday and they beat Rhode Island. But they lost to both, so there's no gain through tie-breakers. They can also finish in a two-way for fifth with either of the aforementioned teams, but still lose on head-to-head tiebreakers with either.

They can also finish in sixth outright at either 8-6 id Dayton and Charlotte win above them. But, they can also be tied at sixth with a loss and a win or wins by St. Bonaventure and Richmond, which will be at Charlotte. St. Joseph's wins that two-way or three-way by virtual of the Hawks' wins over both.

We don't have to go into the next situation, locally, but we will mathematically note that if St. Bonaventure and Richmond lose, while Duquesne, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Saint Louis win, a six-way tie will exist for seventh.

It may come down to casting lots to break that tie or it may be done via Linda Bruno cutting a few deals to trade members with the CAA in one of her final acts as commissioner.

All that said, here are what all La Salle fans need to know other than the best ways to get around the Explorers' campus neighborhood at rush hour, let alone the Tom Gola Arena parking lot.

Obviously, a loss means Lochner will be joining us on the social circuit at St. Joe's next weekend and Hightower will attempt to land a tryout in the WNBA. She's also one of nine finalists for the Lowe's Senior CLASS Award, so don't fret over her ability to land a job somewhere.

But if La Salle wins, they will be involved in one of eight tie-breaking situations to get into the tournament, let alone seed, and the Explorers win out in all but one. Furthermore, with every game Saturday determined before the Explorers take the floor, they will know exactly what they're looking at in terms of extending their season.

The one thing they don't want to hear looming ahead is a three-way tie for 11th with Duquesne and Massachusetts. The reason is in all scenarios above two-team head-to-heads, the records against each other as a group becomes the first tie-breaker to eliminate a team before continuing busting the deadlock for seeding among the survivors.

Here's how La Salle loses out. All three are 1-1, the Explorers deprived of a 2-0 because of a 66-63 loss at home to the Minutewomen. Therefore, records against the top teams in the conference in descending order are used.

All three are 0-1 against George Washington, 0-1 against Temple, assuming the Owls win today over Masachusetts. All three are 0-3 against Xavier. All three are 0-3 against Charlotte. But, against Dayton, whose Jim Jabir is a strong conference coach-of-the-year candidate, Duquesne and Massachusetts have wins, while, in a game we covered, La Salle lost in the final seconds at home, 45-43, to the Flyers, eliminating them from the tie.
Duquesne then gets the 11th seed off a win over Massachusetts, which becomes 12th.

Now, here are all the ways La Salle advances with a win.

(A) Two-way tie with Duquesne for 12th -- La Salle wins the head-to-head.

(B) Three-way tie for 11th among La Salle, Duquesne and Rhode Island

LaSalle moves forward at 2-0. Rhode Island eliminated at 0-2.

(C) Three-way tie for 11th among La Salle, Duquesne, and St. Louis, which starts Saturday's fun at noon at Dayton.

La Salle moves forward at 2-0.

Duquesne eliminated at 0-2

(D) Four-way tie for 10th with Duquesne, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island.

La Salle and Duquesne survive at 2-1. Massachusetts survives at 2-2, having played home-and-home with Rhode Island. Rams eliminated at 1-3. Then, in a three-way tie-break La Salle gets the 12th and final seed off same tie-break for 11th that would have eliminated La Salle. Then Duquesne gets the 10th seed off a win over Massachusetts, which is 11th.

(E) Four-way tie for 10th with Duquesne, Rhode Island, and St. Louis.

La Salle is 3-0 and gets the 10th seed, while other three are 1-2 and we didn't figure the tie-breaks here beyond La Salle's survival.

(F) And, in a five-way scenario for ninth, which quite possibly might happen, with Duquesne, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and St. Louis:

The group-against each other tiebreak gives La Salle the ninth seed off these records:

La Salle: 3-1
Duquesne 2-2
St. Louis 2-2
Massachusetts 2-3
Rhode Island 2-3.

St. Louis then gets the 10th seed off the head-to-head win with Duquesne, which gets the 11th seed. Now, depending who finishes higher between Dayton and Charlotte determines this.
If Dayton is higher, Massachusetts has a win and becomes the 12th seed, URI eliminated.
If Charlotte is higher, Rhode Island becomes the 12th seed with a win, Massachusetts eliminted.

That said, click the page jump button here and we'll talk about the Big East

Big East I: Rutgers and Connecticut Maintain Title Drive

Before discussing Villanova, lett's talk about the top of the conference first, which is simple: Fourth-ranked Rutgers hosts Syracuse Saturday afternoon as seniors Katie Adams, Matee Ajavon, and Essence Carson say farewell to the Louis A. Brown Athletic Center.

Tied with Top-ranked Connecticut in first place in the Big East and also contending with the Huskies for a No. 1 seed in the NCAA tournament, Rutgers needs a win going into Monday night's showdown in Hartford. Connecticut, which already lost to the Scarlet Knights, will be at DePaul.

Also, a second win over Connecticut could make Rutgers a higher No. 1 seed on the "S" curve in the NCAA draw. But remember, there could be a third game a week from now in the conference title game.

For now, if both lose or both win Saturday, then Monday's game becomes winner-take-all.

If Rutgers wins and Connecticut loses, Saturday, this is the Monday night scenario.

Rutgers win gets the regular season title. A Connectiut Monday night win makes it a tie and Connecticut gets the No. 1 seed because of a win over a higher team as West Virginia, which beat Rutgers.

If Rutgers loses and Connecticut loses Saturday. A Rutgers win gets the No. 1 seed off a sweep. A Rutgers loss could drop the Scarlet Knights to a No. 3 seed if West Virginia, coupled in this scenario, beats Louisville at home Saturday and Syracuse on the road Monday night.

If this happens, we'll talk NCAA situation afterwards.It's just not worth getting into now because of what all must happen. Actually, if Connecticut loses at DePaul and to Rutgers, a win over West Virginia, should they be tied for second, gets the Huskies the No. 2 seed.

Villanova Seeks Tourney Return After Year's Absence

The Wildcats at 15-12 and 5-9 in the conference are much improved over a year ago, but still fighting for one of the two remaining berths. A year from now all 16 teams will compete.

A win at home Saturday afternoon puts coach Harry Perretta and his bunch back into the conference playoffs, for however short they'll last against the heavyweights at the top of the conference.

Villanova will finish up at Louisville as an underdog Monday night.

They Wildcats could lose both and still go. A tie with Seton Hall and South Florida -- Villanova is two games up with two to go at the moment -- would be trouble because the Pirates and the NCAA Final Four hosts have beaten the Mainliners.

However, both teams will have trouble making up the two games to catch the Wildcats.

Seton Hall travels to Notre Dame, Saturday, so a loss eliminates the Pirates from knocking out the Wildcats if both have Saturday setback. The Pirates host DePaul, Monday,in another tough game.

South Florida hosts Pittsburghy, Saturday, and what went for Seton Hall in terms of Villanova, applies here. They then go to Marquette Monday night.

Georgetown, meanwhile, with a loss to Villanova, and one game behind the Wildcats, hosts Providence Saturday, and then goes to Pittsburgh Monday night.

St. John's, which is tied with the Wildcats in the loss column, has a loss to Villanova, and will finish its two games at Cincinnati, Saturday, and hosting Notre Dame, Monday night.

We will be back to update this section on Saturday night.

Tight Races Elsewhere.

Cornell fell at the buzzer Saturday night to Dartmouth in the Ivy League, causing a tie with the Big Red and Hartford, whom Cornell will visit Saturday night. The winner takes a one-game lead with two remaining.Third-place Dartmouth is a game behind the leaders.

North Carolina, trying to finish the ACC unbeaten, hosts Duke, Sunday, while Maryland, a game behind, finishes with North Carolina State that needs to quickly repeat the Wolfpack run of a year ago.

Baylor has a one-game lead over Oklahoma and Oklahoma State in the Big 12.

Marist is in a tight race with perfection, needing a home win Saturday against St. Peter's to go unbeaten in the MAAC. The Red Foxes, with their first-ever AP ranking, are one of the few teams likely to be rescued with an at-large bid if upset in tournaments considered one-bid worthy.

Illinois State has a one-game lead over Evansville in the Missouri Valley, while Ohio State and Iowa are tied in the not-so-Big Ten a game ahead of Purdue.

Robert Morris and Quinnipiac are tied for first in the Northeast Conference, while Stanford and California are likewise in the Pac-10.

American has a one-game lead over Army, Lehigh and Holy Cross in the Patriot League.

Tennessee travels to Georgia, Sunday, trailing LSU in the SEC.

Chattanooga is perfect in the Southern, while Boise State and Fresno are tied in the loss column in the Western Athletic Conference.

--Mel

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Philly.com discussions are intended to be civil, friendly conversations. Please treat other participants with respect and in a way that you would want to be treated. You are responsible for what you say. And please, stay on topic.

These boards are monitored by Philly.com staff. We reserve the right at all times to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable to us in our sole discretion and to disclose any information necessary to satisfy the law, regulation, or government request. Personal attacks, especially on other board participants, are not permitted. We reserve the right to permanently block any user who violates these terms and conditions.

Copyright © 2006-2008 Philadelphia Newspapers L.L.C. All Rights Reserved.

Authors

mel_headshot_2.jpg

Mel Greenberg covers college and professional women’s basketball for the Philadelphia Inquirer, where he has worked for 38 years. Greenberg pioneered national coverage of the game, including the original Top 25 women's college poll. His knowledge has earned him nicknames such as "The Guru" and "The Godfather," as well as induction into the Women's Basketball Hall of Fame in 2007.

womhoops_headshot.JPG

Jonathan Tannenwald is a producer with Philly.com. In addition to covering the local college scene, he spent two years as the Washington Mystics beat writer for Women's Hoops Guru. He also writes his own blog, Soft Pretzel Logic, which covers men's college basketball, football, and a variety of other sports.

Other contributors

-- Erin Semagin Damio covers the University of Connecticut and the WNBA's Connecticut Sun for the blog, and contributes other features. The Storrs, Conn., native also attends Northeastern University, where she is a coxswain on the varsity crew team.

-- Acacia O'Connor is in her senior year at Vassar College, where she played on the school's varsity team before going abroad to Bologna, Italy, last spring. From Bologna, she wrote regular dispatches on basketball and culture.

To read the old version of Women's Hoops Guru, click here.

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on March 1, 2008 1:34 AM.

The previous post in this blog was Guru Takes a Technological Time-Out.

The next post in this blog is Rutgers Seniors Bid Adieu Discussing Their Legacy.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.35