« District 8: Feelings of frustration, optimism | Main | Wrapping up the "Presenting the Agenda" forums »

District 7: Many issues raised; many ideas offered

Citizen blogger Albert Yee brings us the final report from our "Presenting the Agenda" neighborhood forums. He writes:

Yee7_1_375.jpg

My final Great Expectations agenda forum was in District 7 - the home turf of freshman Councilwoman Maria Quiñones-Sánchez. The forum was held in Holy Innocents Church in Junianta. Along with about six staffers were about 40 participants. Councilwoman Sánchez and Councilman Bill Green made it out to hear their constituents discuss the agenda.

Yee7_2_275.jpg

I sat down with the breakout group that discussed Budget & Taxes, Leadership & Reform, Transportation and City Services more in depth. This group was definitely the most subdued out of the four I've sat down with in the past month or so, but still had some lively conversation on some points. The discussion started with transportation. Duane wanted to see incentives for not taking cars into Center City like in some other large cities. Adan, a church leader from Norris Square, wanted to see how the city could become greener and address the issue of clogged streets in one fell swoop. James, a PhillyCarShare advocate, wanted to try new ideas and see if the worked out. He wanted smaller vehicles to run late at night instead of the large double-length buses, which run up and down Broad Street with single-digit passengers. John was worried about privatizing I-80. He definitely wanted more money to fund mass transit, but thought that this option would bust the unions and lead to crony appointments.

Yee7_3_375.jpg

John (at left) started off the Leadership & Reform discussion with a blood-roiling demand for his area to be un-gerrymandered. His neighborhood (now part of Councilman Darrell Clarke's 5th) is the one of the worst gerrymandered districts in the nation. John claimed Clarke gerrymandered the district to protect currently jailed former councilman Rick Mariano to prevent the 7th from being won by anyone looking like Ms. Sánchez (but she persevered!). Duane asked who the people were who planned the district boundaries in the first place. Duane also wanted to see the public financing of elections to agreement by several in the group. But John disagreed, saying that would simply make offices even easier to buy by the wealthy.

Yee7_4_300.jpg

Epi (above) had a personal story about his experience with City Services. Around where he lives, in the 7th, there is an abandoned building with lots of squatters; people have been living there with no running water or electricity for months. He says that whenever he calls the police, they come down, get the people to leave and then those people just come back the next day and the police don't come back. He wanted to know whom to call to get a better response. A perfect segue to the proposed 311 and CityStat systems. John was very much in favor of such a system so he wouldn't have to be worried about making non-emergency calls to 911 and tying up the lines. A 311 system would allow those non-emergency issues to be addressed. David asked how to get people to like what they do for a living, how to motivate the trash collectors to do a better job. He said that if trash collection were to be privatized, efficient routes would be able to get bonuses and that would provide the incentive to do a better job.

Yee7_5_375.jpg

On the issue of taxes, James (above) asked the most prudent question: when to conduct the reassessment of real estate throughout Philadelphia. With 135 square miles to cover, some houses could be assessed at a time when the value of their home is high while others when the value is low. Everyone in the group wanted to reduce the gross receipts tax.

Yee7_6_350.jpg

First up for the Q&A session with the council members was John from my group. He asked about what got him so riled up: gerrymandering. Councilwoman Sánchez acknowledged that it was rated the 3rd worst gerrymandered district in the nation and that it was all about incumbency. She said that she's already started talks with Councilman Clarke about re-districting and that it would take place in 2011.

Yee7_7_375.jpg

Sister Elaine asked about a program that might actually go into effect as a result of this forum. The question from her group was to see if unused office space could be donated to new business and be written off as a donation by the owners of the properties. Councilman Green said that this was something to definitely pursue. (AWESOME.) He noted that in Center City, there was approximately 90% occupation, but that 10% was still a considerable amount of square footage sitting empty. He wasn't sure if it was possible under federal code to be able to write off the space as a donation for tax purposes, but promised that he'd look into the issue. Councilwoman Sánchez agreed that it was something well worth the research and that it would be a good way to attract more new business.

Yee7_8_375.jpg

Delores wanted to know what Council would do to fight for city schools and warned the council members to not use the state control of schools as a cop out. Councilwoman Sánchez said that she and Councilman Green were the only ones on Council with school-age children and that made it that much more difficult to push schools to the front of the agenda. But Mayor Nutter has promised to be the education mayor (and he's got a star pupil himself), but he'll have to back up his words with action. She was excited to announce, with Councilwoman Jannie Blackwell's permission (as Chair of the Education committee), that Council will be taking the show on the road and holding sessions in schools all around the city. She also stressed the need to redraw the school district lines as the Northeast is booming with new residents and growing school-age kids. The number of kids being bused far away for school has to be reduced.

Yee7_9_250.jpg

Councilman Green said that the problem wasn't just the school districts. He noted that 37% of school kids are living in poverty; 25% of Philadelphia is living in poverty. The 45% drop-out rate is partly a result of kids in school not seeing the value of an education; they don't see jobs for educated people in the city they live in, so why bother, Green said. He wants to expand the REACH program in Harrisburg to give kids hope. He said this expansion would be paid for by a cigarette tax (didn't specify if it would be a new tax or part of the existing one) and state lottery money. He stressed that kids must see hope and parents must see possibilities. The next question piggy-backed on the education theme and wanted to hear the council members' thoughts on vouchers: both were against vouchers at this point, but they were also looking more into the voucher programs.

Yee7_10_250.jpg

A questioner called for a citywide CLIP (Community Live Improvement Program), currently a Northeast neighborhood improvement program stressing neighborhood parks. Councilwoman Sánchez said that there are already plans for a better CLIP plan with 7 "zones" in her district using the CLIP model. She added that Council must figure out what's working best in the parks right now and to see what's not working. Councilman Green noted that during the primaries, he, Councilwoman Sánchez and Councilman Curtis Jones met to discuss matters relating to city clean up. He cited a figure of 1,200 current sanitation workers while there used to be 2,500 not too long ago. (I believe under Mayor Rizzo.) Councilwoman Sánchez reminded Councilman Green that the three of them agreed to go on a trash run with sanitation workers to see the routes and look at the problems firsthand.

Yee7_11_250.jpg

So that ends my round of reporting from four corners of the city. I urge everyone to take a look through the agenda to see what you like and what you'd like to see addressed more efficiently. Find out who your representative on City Council is and don't forget, there are seven at-large members who are beholden to you as well. If you call, their staff will listen. Call the Mayor's Office and tell them how they're doing so far; give them a progress report, Mayor Nutter, after all, did ask for a report card in January of 2009. So go ahead, step up to the mic; it won't bite.

A flickr set of the photos above a little bigger and a few that didn't make it into the post.

Comments (4)

Anonymous:

Great report, Jodie Chester. Thanks for that. Few notes to the At-largers:

1. We don't have to have every street cleaner be a city worker with city health and pension benefits. We can have the Streets Dept. contract out for those services, or simply give grants to organizations that already do that kind of work, like the Center City Residents' Association (which does the CC clean up) or the South of South Street Neighborhood Association, or SOSNA. Both of these groups hire trash sweeping regularly, such as from the DOE Fund, or Ready, Willing, and Able, and professional clean up/haulers. The Streets Dept. can add to this quorum to get a critical mass of regular, weekly mechanical street cleaning services on all city commercial corridors (any street with several businesses on it).

2. We can't get around collecting overdue property taxes and correctly assessing what people owe. There are still $494 million in overdue taxes outstanding, owed, and unpaid to the city. 60% of that would go right to schools. There's your funding for new schools/better schools issues RIGHT THERE.

www.hallwatch.org/proptax/about/redelinq/stats/summary

3. The NE pays its fair share in taxes, but at-largers have to get on the Council reps that want to let this bill slide in the other districts -- some of which have HALF of all owners owing the city long overdue property taxes for infrastructure, schools, safety, etc.

www.hallwatch.org/proptax/about/redelinq/stats/delinqbyzip/index_html?skey=pcent&rkey=pcent

It's not fair that collections are vigorous in the NE, but less so in other councilmanic areas. It's just as illegal and nonuniform to favor letting overdue taxes slide in one area as it is to not assess property taxes uniformly according to state law.

The diplomats who have to negotiate these issues -- At Large Council Reps.

If zip code 19133 can be allowed to have 41% of all owners owing back property taxes but 19154 has only 4% of all owners not paying, we have a gross, institutional, actionable discrepancy in how property taxes are collected here.

Taxes have to be collected just as diligently in the lower NE as they are in the upper NE. Schools, safe streets, clean communities and good infrastructure need everyone to contribute their fair share.

Why?

Elizabeth McDonald:

I live in part of the 7th District that was given to Daryl Clarke. I never understood how or why this was done until I read this report. While Daryle Clarke seems to be an asset to City Council, I fail to understand what he knows about my area as he has represented the Girard Ave area for some time.

Elizabeth,
Well, Ms. Sanchez is working on fixing the problem in your area. But unfortunately, nothing will change until 2011 at the earliest.

Katherine Lopez:

In today's (3.26.08) Inquirer Opinion page; "Cherry Hill Recycling" I secretly hoped that such an inovative system would be implemented here. Some ideas are installing solar panels on the township municipal building, replacing old light bulbs with low-energy, longer-lasting bulbs, and giving residents incentives to recycle was inspriring. All of our restaurants and business should have a mandatory recycling as well as all business. Yes I'be been told that there is but NO ONE IS ENFORCING THIS! It's frustrating to say the least. And litter bugs should be fined too.

Post a comment

Philly.com discussions are intended to be civil, friendly conversations. Please treat other participants with respect and in a way that you would want to be treated. You are responsible for what you say. And please, stay on topic.

These boards are monitored by Philly.com staff. We reserve the right at all times to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable to us in our sole discretion and to disclose any information necessary to satisfy the law, regulation, or government request. Personal attacks, especially on other board participants, are not permitted. We reserve the right to permanently block any user who violates these terms and conditions.

Authors

blogart.jpg

Great Expectations is a civic engagement project brought to you by The Inquirer and the University of Pennsylvania. Check out the Great Expectations Web site.

Chris Satullo is an Inquirer columnist and former editor of The Inquirer's Editorial Page. He was a founder of the Great Expectations project, which focuses on civic engagement and the issues in Philadelphia's 2007 mayoral race.

Tom Ferrick, a former Inquirer reporter, worked on the Great Expectations project throughout 2007 and into 2008.

Other members of the Editorial Board will be weighing in on the blog, as will Harris Sokoloff and Jodie Chester Lowe, members of the Great Expectations team.

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on March 15, 2008 2:03 AM.

The previous post in this blog was District 8: Feelings of frustration, optimism.

The next post in this blog is Wrapping up the "Presenting the Agenda" forums.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.35